Showing posts with label Homosexuality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Homosexuality. Show all posts

Belated reviews of TIFF 2013 Films

submit to reddit

Le Grande Bellezza
So let's get to it, the list of films I'd seen from best to not really all that great.

1. Le Grande Bellezza (The Great Beauty; Sorrentino): An absurd, energetic, sumptuous feast for the senses, the like of which you'd think Italy no longer produces. This is old school spectacular film making (yes, think La Dolce Vita, any Fellini film really), and yet its relevant modern examination shows just how timeless classic films are. As it is Italy's entry for Foreign Oscars, I can only hope that by some miracle the Academy sees the film and votes for it. My eyes were dancing in their sockets.

2. La Vie d'Adèle – Chapitres 1 & 2 (Blue is the warmest colour; Kechiche): The more you read about this film, the less you'd probably like it. Well, at least that's what happened to me. There's something very off putting about this whole behind the scene gossip regarding the alleged tortured artistic process they went through. But I must remember the first time I sat down to watch the film. It was emotional, if I may put it lightly. Nay, it was a flooded experience. Adèle made it happen. Without her raw vulnerability, this would have just been an exploitative exercise (sorry Kechiche). However, unlike many of the films with strong female leads, the coming-of-age storyboard for the main characters is strong enough to withstand critical examination (thanks Kechiche). See it, not for the long lesbian sex scene (well, if you must), but for the vicarious experience of falling absolutely, resolutely, carnally in love.

3. Poziția copilului (Child's pose; Netzer): I don't know what's going on Romania but there are great films coming out of its woods every year, each astonishes in its own way. At its core, here is a journey to redemption, which really starts with accepting responsibility and the pain that comes with it. Character-driven and naturalistic in its unfolding of events, Călin Peter Netzer's film boasts a handful of strong, unexpected performances. Again, I hope the Academy sees the film and votes for it (Romania's entry), though, just like Beauty, this somewhat demanding film has no chance in hell of winning.

4. Tian zhu ding (A touch of sin; Jia): Holy magnolia, Jia went off the ledge. He's not known for bloody films so it's a bit of a surprise to see the seemingly inexplicable violence that ensues in each tableau. The characters are connected by magic, or flu virus, whichever the touch of evil maybe. Jia himself sees the film as a bit of a fantasy, as he uses the "wuxia" form as the backbone for his broad strokes. He does not explain the motivations too much - it's almost like you're reading breaking news on crimes. You know the details, the parties involved, the fear, but you don't know exactly why it has to happen just then. There's a surreal quality to the picture, so you are removed somewhat from what happens on screen, but not far enough that you leave untouched. It's a difficult but worthwhile film to see, especially if you're a Jia Zhangke fan.

5. Soshite chichi ni naru (Like father like son; Koreeda): There's a casual, no fuss style about this film. I am a huge fan of Koreeda, so naturally I ate this up. The man showed up to his own premiere in sweat pants, running shoes, and a long sweater. How can you not love him? For someone who captures such exact performances from children, you'd think he'd be aces at being a dad. He confessed, however, that he was much more like the aloof father in the film. Maybe that's why he wanted to put in that ending, which was the tidiest that I've seen from him. I must admit though, it is a lesser film from Koreeda. I enjoyed it, but it didn't shake me like his previous ones (After Life, Nobody Knows). They can't all be monumental I guess.

6. Kaze Tachinu (The wind rises; Miyazaki): There's not much to say about the film, other than everything you'd expect from Miyazaki minus the fantasy part is in the picture. There's a love story, but don't expect any overflow of emotions. He has to be the gentlest film maker there is. Even his earthquake is warm. It's definitely a "mature" film, but it is a smaller jewel in his studded crown.

7. Le Passé (The Past; Farhadi): It's a mildly disappointing follow up to the amazing "A Separation" by the promising Iranian director, Farhadi. You can see the intricate dramatic plot deftly being worked out on screen, but the sum of its weight is less than its parts. There's a general sense of "so what?" by the end of the film. I think he still got the human drama right. He just needs a different story, and a little less beating around the proverbial bush.

8. Blood ties (Canet): I don't know why I went to see it - I hated Canet's Little White Lies, and thought he was very mediocre as a director. Well, I live to regret it, because now I can't remember anything good about it. Oh, Clive Owen was decent. That's about it.

9. Moebius (Kim): I rarely ever get the sense that a director is just screwing with me, but watching Moebius, I really thought Kim Ki-duk did just that. Let me describe the film to you: it's a silent film (as in: no dialogue) about desire that involves incest, masturbation by way of physical pain, and castrations (Freudian impulses galore!). The drama is so beyond ridiculous that you can only laugh at what's on the screen. I'm sure that's the intended effect, but I don't qualify this as a valuable way of spending my time. If you're in for good ol' shock value, then you're in the right screening. Just don't expect too much depth, despite what the director believes he's bringing to the equation.

Read More...

TIFF review, Day 3: Little White Lies, in friends we trust

submit to reddit

Title: Les petits mouchoirs (Little White Lies)
Director: Guillaume Canet
Language: French
Year: 2010
Critical Reception: TIFF 2010 entry
Psych Index: Homosexuality, Intimate, Family Relations
In Brief: The story centered around a tightly knit group of well-to-do but troubled friends shaken by an accident befalling one of its members. The actors fully inhibited the picture, creating an aura of warmth and sentiments while trying to keep their darker corners in check. At times, the director (and writer) gave into personal indulgence and made the film overly sentimental (and long) when it did not need to be. Nevertheless, Lies was a sweet little film about friendship and, though the director thought differently, the little white lies that greased it along the way.
Comment (SPOILERS ALERT): Les petits mouchoirs (Little white lies; Canet, 2010) made its debut at the Toronto International Film Festival to much chaos: the initial program ran into the second subtitling problem I encountered at the festival, much to the cast-on-hand's dismay. Canet, invoking the film's friendship theme, persuaded his captive audience into forgiving the technical difficulties that led to hours of waiting in line for the film. While the audience ultimately was soothed by the film's character charms, the dramedy, like the screening schedule, depended too much on the audience's good will and ran on way longer than it should have.

The gently told story centered around a tightly knit, mostly thirty something group of friends attempting to get on with their pre-planned vacation - and their life - at a beach-side cabin owned by its eldest member, Max (Francois Cluzet), after an accident that left one of their own (Jean Dujardin) in a life-threatening condition. Their friendships were tested by secrets and the revelations thereof, the most severe (and effectively handled) of which was Vincent's (Benoit Magimel) confessed feelings for the tightly wound and possibly homophobic Max. Other characters struggled with their own heartache, blinded by self interests and deceptions, until the weight of their drama, like Max's little weasels, broke their wall (Max literally did that in a fit of rage, as obvious a metaphor as it comes). Lies may be necessary at times, but as these characters found out, there comes a time when the consequences of living a white lie get a little too costly (perhaps a slight commentary on the closeted homosexuals out there). And it was practically impossible to contain consequences once personal lies become shared secrets.

Canet did not shy away from courting the English-speaking audience looking for a little crowd-pleasing foreign title to feel good about: he scored his entire film with well known English songs at opportune times. It was perhaps not surprising that he chose the English-subtitled screening for his Q&A when given the choice to speak at length with either a French audience or an English-speaking one. Unfortunately, his ambition - or, as he confessed at the Q&A, his affinity for songs in the English language - detracted from the cast's terrific ensemble work. Having a character (Marie's musician boyfriend) belting out a couple of English songs on the acoustic guitar for his French-speaking group of friends rendered a rather delicate moment false and trying.

While the script fell apart in the maudlin final act, the film as a whole was lifted by the strength of its well-observed characters. There was a sense of a natural, easy camaraderie that helped burrow the group in the audience's emotional space. They had the sort of friendship that people could fantasize about - having intimate connections with really attractive people, aided by a touch of drama and deception, well within the safe confines of ready forgiveness. Despite the obvious privileges that threatened to distant much of the group from the sympathetic viewers, their genuine portrayal humanized their struggle and saved the film from being completely swallowed by wishful sentiments. Canet may have written the film as a love letter to his friends, but as confessional cinema, it felt a little too wanting to truly convey the depth of its universal theme.

Clip:

Read More...

Brüno: Putting sex in homosexuals

submit to reddit

Title: Brüno
Director: Sasha Baron Cohen
Language: English
Year: 2009
Critical Reception: Village Voice's J. Hoberman's stamp of approval
Psych Index: Gender, Homosexuality, Social Relations
In Brief: On the surface, Brüno was a shockingly vulgar and serious (!) picture intended to poke fun at homophobia. However, Cohen was not satisfied with this singular purpose (one which he nevertheless used to dress the overall veneer of the picture). Simmering just underneath was a commentary at the extent that people would go through to achieve fame in America, whether by latching on to a charity cause or by accessorizing with babies. One may claim Brüno to have failed, on a personal level, as a comedy. It happens – I laughed a lot, because I’m crude and such. But to the extent that it outraged on sexual vulgarity or made fools of its targets, it had much to applaud for.

Comment (SPOILERS ALERT):

Poor Ron Paul. The esteemed doctor cum 2008 presidential candidate with a dedicate following thought he was being interviewed on the issue of Austrian economics (who knew he was so keen on it?). What awaited him instead when a light suddenly ‘broke’ mid-interview was a flaming homosexual entrapment. Brüno dropped his pants in a seductive dance, and Dr. Paul stormed out of the interview, but not before declaring Brüno to be a queer. Le duh, Ron Paul! Suddenly it was not all theoretical and academic now, was it? The queer guy was in your space, ‘imposing’ his sexuality in what must be the imagined worse case scenario for those who fear the gay epidemic. Where was the politeness, or decency, for straight’s sake?

One could argue that anyone in his situation would have done the same; after all, who wouldn’t be creeped out by a fit man dropping his pants while waiting to go on with the rest of an interview on economics? And following such an incident, one would totally be entitled to fume away in anger and label such a man as a ‘queer.’ That was what was wrong with the whole deal, obviously – that and the fact that he dropped his pants made it all too frighteningly real. Furthermore, it must be taken into account that Dr. Paul was an old man who had never heard of Borat, and the last films he watched were Gone with the Wind and uh, The Sound of Music, both of which were never gay in their (his) time (but are totally flaming now – try admitting that to your friends). Did Sasha Baron Cohen aim too far out in desperation? Was this an instance of unnecessary mean-ness for shock value? What was the point of putting the poor doctor through such a seemingly no-win situation?

On the surface, Brüno was a shockingly vulgar and serious (!) picture intended to poke fun at homophobia. However, Cohen was not satisfied with this singular purpose (one which he nevertheless used to dress the overall veneer of the picture). Simmering just underneath was a commentary at the extent that people would go through to achieve fame in America, whether by latching on to a charity cause or by accessorizing with babies. Few things could be as desperately sad and shockingly appalling as the sequence in which stage parents consented to having their children put through anything for money and fame, even if it meant to have their children being near ‘antiquated machinery’ or dressing up as Nazis in a burn-the-Jews scenario. The irony was that there was a baby in the film – somebody must have consented to have this baby appeared in the same movie as a talking penis! How was that food for thought, Mr. Cohen? And what of banking on one’s flaming sexuality for fame, as Brüno surely now achieves the fame by doing just that? Is Perez Hilton taking notes? Perhaps this was the most astute observation from the film, one that Brüno the film itself was relying on for success – anyone can be a celebrity for any reason, and it really helps to be willful and exhibit no shame about giving what is asked for (in this case, homosexuality, topic du jour).

There may be very good reasons one could cite for not liking this picture without having to admit to being uncomfortable with homosexuality. If it was not the sexual vulgarity then it was the comedy, and both have been used in criticisms regarding the film. Though the outrageous humour remained intact, Brüno was no Borat: lighthearted silliness was almost absent from the film. In place this time around was an absolutely fearless kind of guerrilla comedy, one that was serious, bold, and dangerous (I thought to myself that Mr. Cohen must have had a death wish at several points in the film). There were lots more intended shocks and less emphasis on instantaneous, laugh-o-meter comedy. Not all comedy needed to be so obvious, but different strokes for different folks – one should not feel obligated to laugh out of shock. As for the sexual vulgarity, I would argue that Cohen did the right thing and went all out with all the possible cliche and feared imagined scenarios one could possibly cram in a film. I mean, could one really talk about homosexuality without the sex?

Some people may like to think sexual orientation in ideas, rather than anything to do with sex. When Brüno decided that it may help his celebrity quest if he was straight, he enlisted gay converters to show him the way. One second-stage gay converter started to rattle on about putting up with women’s irritating presence so they could be near women, because it was good for them men, presumably morally and perhaps sexually. Brüno looked genuinely confused – he may be gay but that had nothing to do with being anti-women. It was the sex, stupid, he responded incredulously (okay not in so many words, but you get the gist). As if that was not clear enough, Brüno struck up a conversation about vaginas with his fellow hunters in his attempt to become straight; what else could they bond over that was ’straight’? In a sequence that surely was staged for effect, Brüno was literally whipped into sexual submission by a caricature of a woman, one that many straight men would masturbate to, judging on the prevalence of such image in the sex industry. Nowhere in the film was there a genuine, sexually desirable woman – but of course, there was no place for her in a film that had nothing to do with her desirability and everything to do with fear of the gays, despite what homophobics may want the public to believe.

One may claim Brüno to have failed, on a personal level, as a comedy. It happens – I laughed a lot, because I’m crude and such. But to the extent that it outraged on sexual vulgarity or made fools of its targets, it had much to applaud for. Sure Dr. Ron Paul, as some people have pointed out, did not object to same sex ‘association,’ but that may have less to do with concerns for equality or acceptance and more to do with his stance regarding the federal government’s role in citizens’ private life. Did he personally think homosexuality was wrong? Who really knows? Does it really matter? Cohen aimed to make it matter, obviously. Empathize with Dr. Paul, if you must, just as you might empathize with other unsuspecting individuals who may have been left a little too exposed for their entitled belief. But satire has never been all that kind. And since homophobics fear sexual relations between same gendered people, it made sense for Brüno to tackle it from an exaggerated sexual frame. If such fear was not the flaming centerpiece, what would be the point of the satire otherwise?

Clip:

Read More...

Eastern Promises: All in the family

submit to reddit

Title: Eastern Promises
Director: David Cronenberg
Language: English, with some Russian
Year: 2007
Critical Reception: People's Choice Award for Best film at the 2007 Toronto International Film Festival. Kudos from Chicago Sun-Times' Roger Ebert, The New York Times' A. O. Scott, Chicago Reader's Johnathan Rosenbaum, Variety's Todd McCarthy,Village's Voice J. Hoberman.
Psych Index: Constructivism, Post-modernism, Narrative Psychology
In Brief: Cronenberg's follow up to A History of Violence began with the death of a teen mother and the birth of her daughter. The midwife who took on the victim's case, Anna (Naomi Watts), with what little information she could obtain from the victim's diary, traced her way to the head of a London-based Russian mafia family, Semyon (Armin Muehller-Stahl). Semyon, determined to protect his family and keep his son's (Vincent Cassell) involvement a dirty little secret, proceeded to keep the matter from surfacing by enlisting the help of Nikolai (Viggo Mortensen), his son's mysterious driver and right hand man. What ensued was a violent game of survival, and Nikolai and Anna found themselves doing what perhaps neither intended to do.
Comment (SPOILERS ALERT):
Comical, absurd, and brutal are all apt adjectives to describe the film. At its heart, Eastern Promises is not only an exercise in genre deconstruction, but also an examination of the new, lonely, postmodern human family. There is no nuclear family to be found anywhere in the film. Instead, each character seems to pick up the separate pieces and attempt to make them whole. This rather constructivistic approach defines the new post modern family: family is what you make of it.

Anna is a newly single woman who lives with her mother, and this family of origin seems to consist of just one other family member: her uncle. Semyon, the head of the Russian mafia family, is a single father. He raises his only son, Kirill, filling both the traditional mother role (he cooks and throws parties) and father role (he's also the breadwinner of the father-son family). Kirill is a playboy, bearing contempt for women, his father, and himself. His love-hate affection extends to his right-hand man, Nikolai, whom he may or may not have sexual feelings towards. He is alone, for everybody - even his father and Nikolai - looks upon him as an isolated, impotent man with little insight about his own situation. Nikolai is a lone ranger with dubious intents and agenda. At one point, he declares to the panel that officially inducts him into the Russian mafia family rank that he has no mother or father. Elsewhere, the father-and-son duo Azim and Ekrim serve as the exclamation mark on the "one is the loneliest number" phrase. Each character yearns for wholeness of family, even when that ideal at times seems like an empty promise.

Within this new societal structure, a different breed of man is born. Nikolai is the new face of post modern man looking for his place atop the chain. His motives are cloaked in uncertainty - uncertainty being a hallmark of postmodernism. Is he or is he not a man of virtuous morality? He declares himself dead at the age of 15 - though one wonders if that's only a front to appease the environment he operates in, or if he is really spiritually barren. He keeps his eyes on the prize, but he also stops to smell the roses. Although he seems flirtatious towards Anna, he does not refuse Kirill's physical and emotional demands. The film is fascinated with the biology of human form, and Nikolai is examined the same way a scientist examines a specimen: his physical form in full, accompanied by his instinctive reactions to his environment. Particularly telling is the incredibly choreographed fight sequence in which Nikolai - in his full animal instinct mode - fights off a couple of men in the nude. "Who are you?" Anna would ask. It would seem that he's our new cave man on display.

Eastern Promises also addresses the hopeful ideal of the grass being greener on the other side. "The West" has been seen as the promised land to many people from all over the world, yearning for a better life. Immigrants to the States, Canada, U.K., etc. know all about the promised land, and the dreams - achieved or broken - that go along with it. Tatianna, the teenage mother, seeks to escape an impoverished life by hanging to the promise of a better life elsewhere - in this case, the East for her. East or West, it seems a matter of narrative construction. Narrative psychology postulates that the meaning we attribute to human behaviour and discourse are largely dependent on the stories we tell ourselves. There are a couple of instances in the film in which a life is told like a story - Tatiana's diary is read many times like a story, and Nikolai's stories are told on his body through the various tattoos as well as his confession to the Russian mafia family. When a person falls into a desperate situation, what s/he tells herself greatly affects his/her decision. The grass seems greener on the other side for Tatiana - both the promise of escape from poverty, and the promise of escape from her miserable condition. In both instances, her action logically follows her narrative, even though it may seem unwise to others. The grass may not be greener, but it gives hope where there's nothing else.

The film also touches on the explosive issues of homosexuality and racism. However, rather than confronting the characters directly, the film lets them live in a bigger world and face the possible consequences of their choice. Kirill may or may not be homosexual (the film strongly alludes to, but does not explicitly states so), yet his affection for Nikolai complicates the extreme defensive reaction he has to others' accusation of his being one. Anna's uncle expresses strong racist remarks, which prompts a subsequent politically correct reprimand follows by a subtler racist scold. He is clearly a product of his environment, and the film refreshingly does not make a moral judgment on his behaviour. It fits in with the way the film is handled - with the detachment and curiosity of a scientist at heart.

The film succeeds in finding the unfamiliarity in the familiarity. It offers a complex take on the face of humanity now. It constructs and deconstructs all at once, making it an ideal film for fans of narrative theory to view. At the very least, it presents a testimony on the loneliness of the world and the need to make the connections wherever we can, as the family unit disintegrates and reforms.

Thoughts in point form:
1. The new 'family' - it's what you make.
2. One is the loneliest number: juxtapose of mafia family and the singleness of family - single mother, single daughter, single uncle, single father, single son.
3. The portrait of a "new" man of power - playing all sides, thirsting for power, but for questionable, ambiguous reasons
4. The fascination with 'man as animal' - even violence seems less about aggression than about reactionary survival measures
5. The undermining form of narrative - unfamiliarity of familiarity, including play-on stereotypes (gay only son, joke about black doctor)
6. Comical, absurd, brutal violence
7. Image of unarmed man against archaic form of arms - animalistic
8. Brave performance, great score, daft direction
9. "eastern promises" play on "western promises" - "the grass is greener on the other side", looking for ideals that ultimately don't deliver
10. brave work is meant to be seen once, as the majority of the audience would be placed in a discomforting zone and wouldn't like to repeat the experience, even though they're provoked by it
11. shares with A History of Violence the fresh take on a familiar genre and a fascination with the biology of violence, but focuses less on violence and more on social loneliness, even though it features one of the most interesting fight sequences committed to the big screen.
12. flirt w/ issues of homosexuality and racism

Clip:


Read More...

 

Recently Seen (out of *****)

  • One night in Miami (King, 2020) ***
  • Mank (Fincher, 2020) ***1/2
  • Coming 2 America (Brewer, 2021) **1/2
  • Ma Rainey's Black Bottom (Wolfe, 2020) ***1/2
  • I care a lot (Blakeson, 2020) **

Copyright © 2016 Cinema Psychologia All rights reserved.
Converted To Blogger Template by Anshul Theme By- WooThemes